1903 – 1906 Prior Alfred Mayer
1906 – 1911 Prior Bruno Doerfler
1911 – 1919 Prior Bruno Doerfler
1919 – 1921 Abbot Michael Ott
1921 – 1927 Father Peter Windschiegel
1924 – 1927 Father Aurelius Rader
1927 – 1931 Father Leo Ojdowski
1931 – 1947 Father Marcellus Mayer
1947 – 1966 Father Gregory Gasser
1903 – 1906 Prior Alfred Mayer
1906 – 1911 Prior Bruno Doerfler
1911 – 1919 Prior Bruno Doerfler
1919 – 1921 Abbot Michael Ott
1921 – 1927 Father Peter Windschiegel
1924 – 1927 Father Aurelius Rader
1927 – 1931 Father Leo Ojdowski
1931 – 1947 Father Marcellus Mayer
1947 – 1966 Father Gregory Gasser
1966 – 1970 Father Joseph Ackerman
1970 – 1977 Father Werner Renneberg
1972 – 1977 Father Rudolph Novecosky, co-pastor
1977 – 1982 Father Leo Hinz
1982 – 1991 Father Martin Brodner
1991 – 1992 Father Lawrence Demong
1992 – 2001 Father Roman Schneider
2001 – 2004 Father Albert Ruetz
2004 – 2015 Father Daniel Muyres
2015 – 2020 Father Paul Paproski
2020 – 2022 Father Demetrius Wasylyniuk
2022 – 2023 Father Colin Roy and Associate Pastor Father John Ezeoruonye
2022 to present Father Paul Oshin